Obama's Tragic Let 'em Out Fantasy - A Review

We are indebted to Heather Mac Donald of the Manhattan Institute for her excellent opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal on Sunday, October 24, 2015, which serves as a warning against the planned one-time release of 6,000 federal prisoners.  She excoriates President Obama for his "preposterous conceit" in equating his own casual drug use with the offenses committed by federal prisoners.  Ms. Mac Donald sets the record straight, with statistics and facts: 

  • The U.S. has much higher crime rates than European nations.

  • Drug treatment programs do not prevent probationers and parolees from committing crimes.

  • Violent criminals and serial thieves make up a large percentage of prison inmates, contrary to one de-incarceration myth.

  • Hispanics, not African Americans, are more likely arrested for drug crimes.

  • Aggressive policing is more likely to reduce crime, but nearly every police and prosecutorial practice is under fire from the left.

  • Demonizing the police is counter-productive and needs to stop.

  • The role of incarceration in reducing American crime will be tested with the release of thousands of federal prisoners.

  • Ms. Mac Donald believes, "We are playing with fire."

According to some research, crime rates go up when a court-ordered release puts many prisoners at once back out on the street. This largest one-time release of 6,000 federal prisoners ought to provide an excellent experiment ... let's see what we learn, and whether we as a society have to learn the hard way.      

Popular posts from this blog

A "Get Out of Jail Free Card" Will Not Work    Most of America's prison reform advocates only approach the issues from the standpoint of the prisoner-as-victim.  Law enforcement policies under the prevailing liberal view are characterized as the main cause and perpetrator of mass incarceration.  We rarely hear these folks tell us what punishment the guilty should have or how criminals should accept the consequences of their crimes.  Many times they propose drug treatment, Drug Court, therapy, commitment to mental institutions, rehabilitation, "alternative sentences," and the extremely general solutions of fairness, equality, education and "community corrections."  Most critics of mass incarceration focus on the process, not the substance of the problems.     The process is flawed, they say, because of the failed War on Drugs, inadequate indigent defense, excessive prosecutorial power, mandatory sentences, exce...
Read more

Who is Biased Against Prison and Sentencing Reform?

Who is Biased Against Prison and Sentencing Reform? by John Dewar Gleissner More people than you think.   Private prison company bias is a no-brainer.   So is the opposition from labor unions for correctional officers.   Politicians naturally do not wish to appear soft on crime, because otherwise they lose their jobs.   Not many prisoners vote or are in the right place to vote.   Some communities need the jobs prisons provide.   The public is biased about crime generally, and believes crime rates are going up when they are actually going down.   Many want prison to be tough and scary.   Crime victims are not too worried about terrible prison conditions, and who can blame them?   Taxpayers are not inclined to spend money on prisons.   Prison walls and fences naturally block the flow of information, commerce and visitors.   Educated, law-abiding and intelligent people do not have much in common with prisoners, and are thus...
Read more

HOW TO CREATE AMERICAN MANUFACTURING JOBS

"How to Create American Manufacturing Jobs" has been published and released by the Tennessee Journal of Law and Policy , a publication of the University of Tennessee Law School.  Citation: Vol. 9 - Issue 2, Tennessee Journal of Law and Policy 161 (Fall 2013), now available on Westlaw.  For those who do not have access to Westlaw, here is a summary: Right now, 50 states and the federal government (not to mention city and county jails) have total control over every single aspect of prison industries.  Total control must give way to more contractual and trade freedom of action.  The United States could create many manufacturing jobs if they would free employers, prisoners and Departments of Correction to manufacture goods in prison free of almost all government employment laws and regulations, and subject to contracts between willing prisoners and willing private manufacturers, who must also contract with the prison systems for space and other accommodatio...
Read more